[VC] Guild War Prizing by Division - September 1st

It is my guess Terror that some players received rewards based on the old formula before Kano realized it. That would explain why some guilds have members who got rewards and also members who did not get rewards. I hope I am wrong and that Kano will fix it for you. Either way, they should have given an explanation by now!

 

Gosh I hope not! The only reply any one of them has received was not a happy one. It stated that he did not receive his rewards because of the guild's behavior on Tavern....WTF is that all about??? The people that did not receive rewards are punished? And since when would anyone be punished and withheld rewards as a punishment.

 

Wondering when we're going to be receiving our rewards, I play on server 2, the guild I'm in was a B team rank 1 overall 8, when I clicked on the collect I didn't receive the rewards:
48 Favor Points
48% XP to level
95x Income
Was the same issue for all members in guild.

 

we were 24th in B and first promised 40 soemthng get reward from that tier now we see only 8 get rewards from each division...
not we havent got rewards yet

 

the rewards are more spread out now then before, so i would say it is more fair now since the B ranks and below can actually get something for all the effort they put forth.

Also kano said they are more then likely going to run both rewards, the one it is now for divisions and the overall(but slightly modified). This was the first go around of the event for all the games so from here on out there is slowly going to be tweaks and adjustments accordingly to find the best balance between awards and ranks between people being active.

as it is now there is a minimum of 30 guilds (6 per division gaining rewards) getting rewards instead of just 20, but soon there is going to be 20% which will have about 40 guilds capable of being awarded. To me that is way more then fair.

 

A guild member took these pictures before I logged in after the last Guild War's, no one was able to collect this so-called reward



By the time I logged on, there wasn't even a pop-up

 

I totally agree with you Dutchman. There is no point in entering guild wars if the odds of getting a reward dropped so drastically. We normally rank in the top 10 and as of late, the competition between the guilds trying to get at least 7th through 10th has been a very close race. I did not mind the challenge and often bought refills to help us out, but with the new formula in place, I see no point in even playing. I do understand that Kano wanted to get the lower guilds more interested in playing, but what they fail to realize is that not all “A” guilds are full of just high level players. We also add lower level players to our guild and those players very much depend on the rewards to get stronger. As it was this last season, they got no rewards to help them build their income or buy needed armory even tho they worked hard to help keep us in the top 10. And the way I see it, you don't just take away rewards that people have become accustomed to getting in the first place! That is just plain messed up!

 

i am asking my guild MIA not to enter this Guild wars as kano has taken any incentive out of the rewards... unless you place top 8 you're pretty much playing for nothing... and thats such a waste of FP

 

Have you contacted support about this? Our response time has been slow of late as we onboard new team members so I apologize for that. If you finished top for Div B you very much should be able to collect. Please PM me your profile link and I'll take a peek. And if you have contacted support please let me know the ticket number so I can reference that too.

cheers

 

Please see my post from yesterday about this:
http://forums.kanoapps.com/threads/...vision-september-1st.34893/page-2#post-183214

Long story short we will be making changes to make it right by the Guilds that are in Div A & B and finish high in the Overall rankings. We will be adjusting this weekend's Guild War to correct this so stay tuned for a formal announcement which should be out tomorrow.

 

This was a bug during the initial collection right after the event ended which has since been fixed. This guild did not finish high enough for end of event rewards unfortunately But please see my comments above, we are going to be making changes for the next event to ensure that the top Overall guilds are getting their due rewards.

 

I need to see the new rewards system before I even consider entering in the guildwars. Hope you do this at an early enough time, so I can see the new setup.

 

that i got too

 

u said 20%%%% from EACH division!! ... 8 only get rewards.. so that is mislead us badly 40 guilds total in each divison then playing?? in my ........

 

*sigh* you didnt read my comment i see... ill try to explain it easier for you.

CURRENTLY AS OF 9/13/17:
The way the rewards work is a minimum of 6 guilds capable of obtaining rewards from each division.
This means that there are 6 from A, B, C, D and E. that is a total of 6 from each multiplied by total divisions. - 6*6= 30 -
30 divisions as of now is the base amount of guilds capable of being awarded for ranking.

POSSIBLE CHANGE IN THE WORKS:
On top of the rewards stated above, 30 minimum amount of people capable of being awarded, there is going to be the original top 20% overall stacked on top of those rewards.
With another 20% stacked, the bare minimum is going to be top 20 overall given a ranking award.
So simply math here and we come to, assuming only A ranks in the top 6, 14 additional rewards for guilds.
That would be the previous stated 30 guilds added to the 14 additional rewards for overall. thats 30+14 which equals 44, but in my last post i was being nice and giving the lower guilds a chance to get in the tops and skew that down to as i stated previously, roughly 40 awards given to guilds.

So how again is this worse then before when it was only the top 20%? more guilds are being awarded in comparison to before. Yet kano is still trying to be nice and appease people by stacking the old rewards on top of it. From the looks of it you are the only person misleading others since you couldnt comprehend my post so decide to make false accusations as if they were fact. Usually its best to ask questions about things you dont understand instead of trying to make blank statements sound as fact.

 

Fair enough Dutchman. We are working on a change right now that will expand the payout ranges for both Div A and Div B to ensure that those Guilds who were used to getting end of event rewards under the old payout structure will continue to do so. Hoping to have that released today so you can see the reward structure ahead of tomorrow's Guild War.

 

Hey all - I just made a new official announcement about this weekend's Guild War: http://forums.kanoapps.com/threads/guild-war-prizing-revisions-september-15th.35068/ As Smack mentioned we'll be expanding these payout ranges so that more guilds in Division A and B get rewards. The updated prizes aren't visible in-game yet, but they should be by later tonight or early tomorrow at the latest.

Thanks for your patience and feedback on this, I know it was a surprise for a lot of people and we definitely want to be awarding competitive factions the prizes they deserve.

 

Thanks fellas- this really does affect the way my guild would or would not even be playing- We are a fringe team and would seldom see the top 8 in Division A. But we are competitive and can try if we know there is something there. Otherwise we would have not been doing refills and we would have been probably calling this our last GW.

 

I personally haven't but my guild leader and officer have sent tickets, they haven't posted any responses yet.

 

I am not impressed I don't know why but the carrot isn't big enough