My stagedy...I will rule out a specific gift and then post it. The way I am going to go about this, using my first gift for example, the boat dog along with one other gift, then testing it against each drop from adventures. I will continue to use the boat dog along with the remaining gifts in the same way to rule each possible combination out. I will let you know soon if the boat dog makes it or becomes ruled out. Oh yes, did I mention that I absolutely hate crafting....it exercises my patience too much. LOL
If anyone is going to use this method...first make sure you have one of each gift. There are 114 of them in all. Make sure you have one of each, and if you craft make sure you do not eliminate one of the gift items. Unless you are sure to replace it before crafting. One missing item would make the ruling out of a gift useless. I will post the gift list at the end, in case you would like to use it for verification. I simply went to the blacksmith, selected a gift item, and then removed the item from the following list once I knew I had it. The gifts that I did not remove were the ones that I asked for. Hope this all helps and I would appreciate any help on this....just please post the gift that you are working on to help others avoid redundancy. If two heads are better than one, then 3 or more must be even better. 
Gift List
1. Assassin Finger
2. Marco Polo Pendant
3. Poppet
4. Clockwork Canary
5. Bog Beast
6. New World Marine
7. Ironhead Destroyer
8. Quadrishot Pistol
9. Skull Mug
10. Binocular Scopes
11. Clockwork Parrot
12. Loaded Dice
13. Secret Letter
14. Lantern
15. Black Powder
16. Star Map
17. Pirate Bandana
18. Palm Tree
19. Wineskin
20. Water Wings
21. Festive Roger
22. Candy Cane Oar
23. Snowglobe
24. Christmas Parrot
25. Egg Grog
26. Naughty List
27. Floatation Wreath
28. Fingers Frigate
29. Fingers Token
30. Fingers Matey
31. Parrot Cage
32. Bag of Winds
33. Ship Wheel
34. Golden Timepiece
35. Treasure Pumpkin
36. Divining Rods
37. Octo Pie
38. Seasick Bucket
39. Mandolin
40. Pirate Toilet Paper
41. Log Book
42. Sextant
43. Ol' Time Camera
44. Glass Eye
45. Pirate Teddy
46. Sail Patch
47. Paddle
48. Seamaster Anchor
49. Mouthy Parrot
50. Sundial
51. Steel Drums
52. Pirate Sandwich
53. Grappling Hook
54. Pirate Towel
55. Emerald
56. Bubble Blower
57. Ropeknot Flair
58. Sealion Tusk
59. Diamond
60. Cockatiel
61. Archimedes Sunfire Mirror
62. Turtle Soup
63. Condor Feather
64. Captain's Daughter
65. Love is a Battleship
66. Cut Me Heart Out Cutlass
67. Boat Canary
68. Sharktooth Necklace
69. Spanish Doubloons
70. Swordfish Blade
71. Topaz Dagger
72. Boat Ferret
73. Ancient Chest
74. Jade Gemstone
75. Frankincense
76. Rudolf
77. Lump of Coal
78. Mistletoe
79. Treasure Chest
80. Pirate Telescope
81. Bottle of Grog
82. Pirate Captain Hat
83. Sea Turtle
84. Letter of Marque
85. Boat Dog
86. Boat Rat
87. Ship's Bell
88. Lion Figurehead
89. Evil Eye Talisman
90. Bronze Eagle
91. Boat Cat
92. Captain's Hook
93. Peg Leg
94. Lucky Shovel
95. Captain's Spy Glass
96. Captain's Rum Flask
97. Bandit Gloves
98. Zombie Dagger
99. Zombie Compass
100. Pirate Tombstone
101. Boxing Gloves
102. Rabbit Skull Bandana
103. Chinese Pirate Sails
104. Pirate Monkey
105. Melee Scimitar
106. Bone Necklace
107. Compass
108. Ship Helm
109. Jolly Roger
110. Dual Scimitars
111. Eye Patch
112. Cannon
113. Silver Hook
114. Parrot
Adventure Drops
Boiler cannon
The Blowfish
Steampunk Sword
Baroness
Tesla Rifle
Steamslinger
Glass eyepatch
Flying frigate
Half metal man
Future Flintstock
Last edited: May 12, 2012