Result:
- Bahama's Bar Shot - 29A/25D
Likely Use:
- Spanish Shipping Schedule (adventure drop) - 4A/4D
Challenge Drops:
- Gold Rapier (Weapon) - 30A/26D
- Ruthless Mateys (Matey) - 21A/15D
- Sloop of War (Ship) - 88A/88D
Adventure Drops:
- Nassau Matey (Matey) - 13A/15D
- Hijacked Warship (Ship) - 85A/87D
Boss Drops:
- Modified Brigantine (Ship, Boss Owner) - 88A/88D
- Privateer (Matey, Boss Helper) - 21A/15D
- Kraken Tooth (Weapon, Minimum Damage) - 23A/30D
- Tentacle Whip (Weapon, Random Award) - 28A/22D
From that list, we can rule out *ALL* of the ships and the Gold Rapier. The Kraken Tooth is a possibility, but extremely unlikely.
We are left with:
- Ruthless Mateys (Matey) - 21A/15D
- Nassau Matey (Matey) - 13A/15D
- Privateer (Matey) - 21A/15D
- Kraken Tooth (Weapon) - 23A/30D
- Tentacle Whip (Weapon) - 28A/22D
I don't have the Ruthless Matey, so I can't try that. But since we are also pretty sure that Weapons make Weapons and Mateys/Ships aren't used, then we assume Spanish Shipping Schedule + Tentacle Whip + gift.
Gifts I have tried:
Jade Gemstone
Spanish Dubloons
Boat Dog
Captain's Spy Glass
Last edited: Mar 12, 2011