Blacksmith - Under Giant recipe ONLY

ONE of the two items comes from something you can get at level 420. I have been told it is the Frost Giant...or the Elder Frost Giant. Makes sense, you use a "Giant" warrior to get a "Giant" warrior.

Two unique items: Kano Shield and Trickster's Blade
Two non-unique items: Kano Shield and Kano Shield

 

The rock giant comes after level 420, the unlock level for the under giant, so it couldn't be part of the puzzle.

 

Has anyone tried the Sword of Ice (Odins Challenge reward)...with the Frost Giant....

also...All Blacksmith items that are warriors require a minium of two warriors....so....if there is only two unique items used......

I'm thinking it is two unique warriors.....

Just a theory...

 

I have tried the sword of ice, if you look above there is a very long list of everything i have tried to combine with the frost giant, elder frost giant and battle etin. It did however occur to me last night that i have not yet done the aegirs passage odins rune challenges, maybe something from them is part of the answer

 

How do you figure that?
There aren't that many warriors open for a level 420 player, ONE of which comes at level 420. As Seth already said, he has tried essentially EVERYTHING with Elder Frost Giant and Frost Giant.

DarkStratus, the Kano Secret Ninja, said that the Under Giant requires 2 unique items to craft.

We know from the Blacksmith listing that the most recent of the items is open AT LEVEL 420.

What We Can Infer:

• I trust what our Secret Ninja told us. So we know there are two different items used.

• Blacksmith says it can be done by a level 420 at the earliest. This means if the higher item is an adventure drop, it comes from the middle of Niflheim. Either the Frost Giant or the Elder Frost Giant is that drop.
  • Furthermore, a Warrior Recipe suggests it uses a Warrior. This makes sense.

• The user "seth the chef" has compiled a long list of items he tried with both of the Frost Giants. Again, we assume he is telling the truth (in this case because he would want to craft it as well) and we can know that the second item is very likely NOT a Warrior.

• Ky76, I have seen nothing that proves all Warrior Recipes need at least 2 Warriors. Nor have I seen anything suggesting that both items here are Warriors.

Seth, are there any items that you did NOT get a chance to test? I've done the Aegir's Passage Rune Challenge but only the first Niflheim Rune Challenge, so I have Aegir's Longship but not the Elder Frost Giant. Could it be the "Billow Maiden," another Aegir's Passage drop?

Frost Giant + Yeti Ice Sword
Frost Giant + Aegir's Longship

I'm trying to think what else I can test with the Frost Giant.
Secret Ninja, could you tell us if gifts are used? If none are, could we know whether they are Warriors or Weapons?

 

I have all the niflheim challenge drops, but none from aegirs passage. There are also several gifts i don't have, which i've been requesting and trying as i obtain them. I haven't had much time the last 2 nights to try new combos but probably will this weekend while all the kids are gone. So hopefully we will get the thing figured out within the next few days

 

Aegir's Passage Challenge had the Aegir's Longship (which I got and tested with the Frost Giant), a Warrior that I do not remember, and another item of type unknown.

D'you know WHICH gifts you haven't tested? I think I have them all and can test with the Frost Giant...leaving the Elder Frost Giant for you (since I have neglected to get it)
I'm in the middle of Vingolf's Challenge and I'll do the remaining Aegir's Passage ones after that. You know...I think the third item was a Warrior.

 

I don't have the viking tunic, long bow, wooden shield, poison arrows, battle chainmail, trained hawk, rabbit shield, wooden rabbit amulet and leather armbands

 

Right then. Testing those gifts with the Frost Giant now. Will edit this post when I find something out.

EDIT:
if the recipe is correct, but I lack the funds or enough of the item, it will say so (this happened with the Hellfire Chariot...I made a screen capture to prove it)
Longbow - nothing
Leather Armbands - nothing
Wooden Rabbit Amulet - nothing
Rabbit Shield - nothing
Wooden Shield - nothing
Poison Arrows - nothing
Viking Tunic - nothing
Battle Chainmail - nothing
Trained Hawk - nothing

I could clan with you and send you any you need.
http://apps.facebook.com/vikingclan/profile/user/715989330

 

number of items

like with the hellfire chariot, you realize the under giant could take a ridiculous number of each of the ingredients? I don't know exactly what kind of "hint" has been given but if it only says "two unique items", that doesn't necessarily mean anything (whishful thinking aside) regarding the number of copies of each... Or would the recipe be unlocked still if one tries with the right combination but insufficient numbers?

 

I answered this in my edited post before I saw your question. No, the recipe is NOT unlocked BUT the Blacksmith tells you the recipe failed because you did not have enough of them. That way you know you have the right combination, and now how many you need versus how many you have.
I've attached proof of this happening when I discovered the Hellfire Chariot recipe.

 

Ninjas? Could we have a little hint, please? Thanks!

 

Hey everybody. I think we are all overlooking an important part of the clue the ninjas gave us. He said "two unique item types" not just unique items. I just re-read all of the posts here. This could possibly mean that we need both giants and a weapon maybe... just tossing out possibilities. Hope it helps. I don't have enough of the ingredients to try much yet.

 

I had asked whether the "unique" was for items or for item types. Urgh, too confusing. And VC only has two item types anyways. Pirate Clan has 3: Matey, Weapon, Ship. All the gifts are Weapons for BOTH of those Clan games. So either that was an unhelpful hint, or we only use two different items (quantity unknown) to make the Under Giant.

Anyways, the level 420 requirement indicates either the Frost Giant or the Elder Frost Giant, ONE of which is unlocked in Niflheim at level 420.
I don't think we know any more than that...and unfortunately I STILL don't have the Elder Frost Giant.
Some hidden recipes use a previous crafted item...is that the case here? Perhaps the second item type (assuming the first is one of the Frost Giants) is the Ice Dart. The only problem is...Ice Dart uses two items from the Niflheim Rune Challenge. Since the Ice Dart is unlocked BEFORE the Under Giant, then the Niflheim Rune Challenge is BEFORE a player reaches level 420. So the level 420 item almost HAS to be the Frost Giant. If so, then anything from before the Frost Giant is fair game, and anything afterward is off-limits.

 

So, I get the impression that it is the Frost Giant with some other item.
Quotes from our beloved Ninja (on page 2 and 3):

Here is all the lists of items that failed to react with the Frost Giant (some tested by me, but most from helpful others) alphabetized:
advent wreath
aegir guard
aegir staff
aegir war ship
aegirs amulet
aegirs armor
aegirs hammer
aegirs longship
aegirs trident
aesir statue
battle ax
battle etin
battle swine
blessed oil
blood decoy
byggvir ale
celtic gorget
chainmail armor
champion ax
champion knives
cyclops smash club
cyclops war helm
death dealer
deluxe spears
drakkar figurehead
elder frost giant
fafnir dragon helm
fenrir
fishing drakkar
fishing spears
forearm armor
forged helm
freyjas armor
freyjas follower
freyjas sword
giant squid
golden apple of youth
great fishing net
hero
hiking boots
hugin and mugin
ice dart
ice shard catapult
iwaz rune
jormungander
kite shield
lands end sentinel
leather helm
lobster breast plate
lobster guantlet
lobster hook whip
long range catapult
lump of coal
mead horn
mini melee ax
mini throwing axes
minotaur flail
minotaur hoof club
minotaur war bow
morning star
njord hook
njord ship
njord warlord
norse prince
north star charm
northern knot charm
obsidian dagger
odins mask
pack horse
pillagers ax
pillagers helm
pillagers tunic
rock giant hammer
rock tunic
ruffian blade
ruffian helm
ruffian tunic
rune chiseled ax
sacred well
scroll of vanir knowledge
serpent claw blade
serpent skin armor
sheild of ice
silver armband
silver ornament
skidbldnir
skull dagger
svalinn sun shield
sword of ice
tentacle whip
thors amulet
thunderstroke mace
torch
training sword
twin minotaur axes
undersea armor
undersea chariot
undersea helm
underworld ring
venom dart
viking costume
viking dagger
viking longship
viking war helm
war boots
war elephant
warrior princess
wolfskin cloak
yeti ice helm
yeti ice mace
yeti ice sword
zombie bat
zombie drakkar
zombie hunting hawk

 

I have just tested the Frost Giant with previous Blacksmith items. However, I do not have the Ice Dart. Would some kind person test it and post their result, please?

 

ice dart did not work with frost giant or elder frost giant

 

I tried the ice dart with both frost giants no luck

 

Elder Frost Giant does not work. There are two items, according to the Ninja. ONE of those is unlocked at level 420. This is the Frost Giant. The Frost Giant will then not make anything with the Elder Giant AND the Ice Dart.
Looking at my list above, does anyone see an item missing? It can NOT be obtained after the Frost Giant as the Under Giant can be crafted by a player at level 420.

 

under giant?

I have been working in the blacksmith trying to find the recipe for under giant, but I have not had any luck. Has anyone else found it yet?